The Ultimate Supplier Performance Evaluation Checklist

By The oboloo Team

The Ultimate Supplier Performance Evaluation Checklist

Steps To Evaluate Suppliers

The success of your business depends on the performance of your suppliers. A poorly performing supplier can negatively affect your bottom line and even put your company at risk. That’s why it’s important to evaluate your suppliers regularly. We will provide you with a quick checklist to help you evaluate supplier performance in this blog post. 

How Does Supplier Evaluation Work?

You evaluate your suppliers’ performance by measuring and monitoring their performance. You can perform this on a regular basis, such as quarterly or annually. Suppliers should be evaluated based on their financial stability, product quality, delivery time, and customer service. Before conducting an evaluation, it’s essential to clearly understand your requirements and expectations. Identifying any areas of weakness will help you evaluate the supplier

What are the Benefits of Supplier Evaluation?

By evaluating suppliers, you can ensure that they meet your standards and requirements. Additionally, you can identify any potential problems that could negatively impact your company. Performing regular evaluations can help you ensure your suppliers are performing at their best, and correct any problems if they arise. 

Managing a global supplier base and varying business rules can be challenging for companies with a global footprint. Developing a comprehensive supplier evaluation plan is crucial for internal and external accountability and justification.

It can be useful in a variety of situations to develop a concrete supplier evaluation plan, such as

In order to reduce costs, increase efficiency, and improve business performance, supplier performance must be measured and evaluated. As a result, they prevent product defects and supply chain issues.

Checklist For Supplier Performance Evaluation

Step 1: Determining performance indicators

It is first important to develop a comprehensive and detailed evaluation plan for suppliers. Without this, the following steps are meaningless, or in worse scenarios, could reveal false insights that are counterproductive to your business. The following parameters should be included in your Supplier KPI checklist:

  • Price

A negotiation can make or break a supplier’s deal, so it’s important to pay attention to it. By leveraging economies of scale, your organization can certainly negotiate lower prices from vendors. As a result, you can take advantage of large or recurring deals with them. Look closely at a company’s commitment to its estimations. If unexpected charges, tax increases, or surprise costs are a regular occurrence, you should be raising red flags.

  • Cost

Costs incurred by your organization (monetary and non-monetary) when dealing with suppliers are another consideration. The major component of the cost is the price of the goods or services procured, but other peripheral expenses include shipping, packaging, and disposal costs.

  • Quantity

Considering the order quantity versus the receipt quantity is also important. Suppliers sometimes send an ASN (Advanced Shipment Notice) explaining anomalies with the delivery.

  • Quality

A product inspection helps to detect any defects, rejections, or returns, etc.

  • Service

Client satisfaction engagement is one of the key indicators of service excellence.

  • Delivery

You will be able to determine your satisfaction with the supplier based on the time frames for the order process and the pre-delivery waiting period.

A flexible payment process offers sourcing organizations much more flexibility than rigid payment terms.

  • Certifications/Accreditations

Getting industry and domain-specific certifications means more than just checking off a box. Suppliers are required to meet a minimum level of quality expectation and a level of trust.

  • Innovation

Those suppliers who put innovation at the center of their offerings are more likely to succeed in the long run than those who are not interested in it.

  • Financial health

Finances that are healthy enable suppliers to provide better service, innovate better, and be more accommodating to longer payment cycles. Also allow the supplier to actually exist to deliver the good or services without putting your supply chain at risk. 

  • Compliance

It is important to check tax compliance, regulatory compliance, and contract compliance. Aside from these general domains, there are also some that are more specific to certain regions 

Step 2: Classifying Suppliers

Comparing suppliers begins with classifying them into categories similar to each other. There are two ways to do this: by type of product and geography.

Step 3: Integrating and centralizing data

Business needs are usually met by 20% of suppliers. If your company has hundreds or thousands of suppliers across many different functions, this can be a challenge. Organise them all in one centralized portal, such as oboloo. 

Step 4: Developing an evaluation strategy

Choosing a period of time to evaluate suppliers is the key to developing a solid evaluation approach, followed by determining the method. Here are a few examples:

Step 5: Working with suppliers to review/feedback

There is no need for all assessments to be quantitative. Rather, constant collaboration between suppliers and buyers can, at times, highlight bottlenecks more clearly. While it’s essential to conduct regular meetings, it’s also crucial to be attentive to the supplier. Feedback conversations eliminate many roadblocks.

Step 6: Developing an action plan

It is now time to develop an actionable plan for each supplier relationship. Also, you should ensure that your findings are acted upon to ensure closure on the evaluation process. In the right combination of people, processes, and technology, supplier performance can work wonders.  Additionally, it identifies performance gaps and devises strategies to plug them.

An Overview of Supplier Evaluation Methods and Approaches

In order to conduct a successful supplier evaluation, you must choose the right approach and method. Supplier performance can be evaluated in a variety of ways. Some companies rate suppliers on a scale of 0-100 using a Supplier Scorecard. Alternatively, some companies may conduct qualitative interviews with customers or employees. 

You should choose the approach that best suits your company’s needs. It is also important to consider the resources at your disposal when making a decision. An in-depth interview may not be feasible for you if you lack time or manpower. 

Tips for Evaluating Suppliers

To help you evaluate suppliers successfully, here are some tips: 

– Setting clear objectives is essential before beginning the evaluation. What are your goals? 

– Establish a set of criteria for evaluating suppliers once you have defined your objectives. Quality, delivery times, customer service, and so forth are all examples of this. 

– To evaluate supplier performance, you will need to collect data from a variety of sources. It could be a financial statement, a customer survey, an employee interview, etc. 

– Data analysis: After you’ve collected all the data you need, it’s time to analyze it. As a result, you will be able to identify any areas where the supplier may be lacking. 

– Your findings may indicate that you must take action to improve supplier performance. Contracts may need to be renegotiated, suppliers may need to be changed, or procedures may need to be amended. 

Benefits Of Supplier Evaluations

A supplier evaluation can be beneficial in many ways. The following are some of the most important benefits:

– Making sure your suppliers meet your standards and requirements. 

– Identifying potential problems that could affect your business. 

Improving the performance of suppliers

–  can identify problems early on and correct them before they negatively impact your bottom line by conducting a regular evaluation. Managing your supply chain involves evaluating suppliers and ensuring you’re getting the best products and services possible.  

How Do You Evaluate Suppliers?

You can ensure the effectiveness and efficiency of your supplier evaluation by following a few key steps. Here are some important steps to follow: 

 Set goals and requirements for the project. 

– Decide which Suppliers you will evaluate

– Collect data and information about suppliers

Perform an analysis of Supplier performance. 

– As a result of findings, take action. 

 These tips will help you conduct an efficient and effective supplier evaluation. Supply chain management involves evaluating suppliers to ensure your company is obtaining the best possible products and services. Conducting regular evaluations can help you identify any problems early on and take corrective action before they negatively impact your business.  

Want to find out more about supplier management?

Access more blogs, articles and FAQ's and discover oboloo's supplier management capibilities

Oboloo transparent

The smarter way to have full visibility & control of your suppliers


Feel free to contact us here. Our support team will get back to you as soon as possible

Oboloo transparent

The smarter way to have full visibility & control of your suppliers


Feel free to contact us here. Our support team will get back to you as soon as possible

© 2024 oboloo Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of oboloo content, including by framing or similar means, is prohibited without the prior written consent of oboloo Limited. oboloo, Be Supplier Smart and the oboloo logo are registered trademarks of oboloo Limited and its affiliated companies. Trademark numbers: UK00003466421 & UK00003575938 Company Number 12420854. ICO Reference Number: ZA764971