To score supplier bids fairly, agree your criteria, weights and scoring scale before any bids arrive, and tell suppliers what they are. Check pass/fail requirements first, then have each evaluator score every bid alone, agree a final score in a moderation meeting, and write down the reason for each score. Price gets its own formula, usually the lowest price divided by each bid's price, times the points available. You can do all of this in a spreadsheet such as an RFP scoring template in Excel, or in sourcing software such as oboloo, where suppliers answer in a portal and weighted scoring by section is part of eSourcing Plus.
Most teams do their weighted scoring in a spreadsheet, and for a single event that is fine. If you run RFPs often, sourcing software holds the weights, collects each evaluator's scores and does the arithmetic for you. oboloo runs the whole event on its free plan, with suppliers answering through a portal, and adds event weighted scoring and scoring analysis on the eSourcing Plus plan. Enterprise tools such as Market Dojo offer weighted events too, on paid licences.
Decide what matters for this purchase and give each criterion a weight, adding up to 100%. Do it before you send the RFP, because once you have seen the prices it is too easy to bend the weights towards a favourite. See how supplier scoring works in oboloo.
Then tell suppliers the criteria and weights in the RFP itself. Public buyers have to. Under the US Federal Acquisition Regulation, all factors that affect the award and their relative importance must be stated clearly in the solicitation. UK guidance under the Procurement Act 2023 says the same: publish the award criteria and how you will assess them, with the relative importance of each. Private buyers are not bound by these rules, but suppliers write better bids when they know what you value, and nobody can say the goalposts moved.
Keep the list short: price (total cost), quality or technical fit, delivery and service, risk and compliance, and experience usually cover it. If you are not sure how to split the weights, our free RFP evaluation scorecard builder suggests weights based on the type of purchase and what matters most to you. For what else belongs in the RFP, see our free RFP checklist.
A number without a definition means different things to different people. Write down what each score means and share it with evaluators (and ideally suppliers).
| Score | What it means |
|---|---|
| 0 | No answer, or the answer does not address the question |
| 1 | Major gaps or serious concerns |
| 2 | Partly meets the requirement, with clear weaknesses |
| 3 | Meets the requirement |
| 4 | Meets the requirement with good evidence and some added value |
| 5 | Exceeds the requirement, with strong evidence and low risk |
Some things are not worth points. They are simply required: the right insurance cover, a required certification, agreeing to your core terms, or meeting a mandatory specification. Check these first as pass or fail. A bid that fails a gate goes no further, however good its price.
Say in the RFP which requirements are pass/fail. UK guidance under the Procurement Act 2023 makes the same point: the assessment method must say if failing a criterion would disqualify a bid.
Each evaluator scores every bid alone, using the descriptors, with a short reason for each score. No comparing notes until everyone is done.
Before anyone opens a bid, ask each evaluator to declare any conflict of interest, such as a friend or relative at a bidding supplier, shares in one, or a recent job offer. If someone has a conflict, move them off the evaluation. UK guidance on the Procurement Act lists reassigning people with a conflict as one way to manage it.
Price is scored by formula, not opinion. The most common one is:
Price score = (lowest price ÷ this bid's price) × maximum price points
The lowest bid gets full marks and the others get a share. Here is a made-up example: price is worth 30 points and quality 70. Quality is the moderated score out of 5, converted to points (score ÷ 5 × 70).
| Supplier | Total price | Price score (out of 30) | Quality score (0 to 5) | Quality points (out of 70) | Total (out of 100) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | £40,000 | 27.0 | 4 | 56 | 83.0 |
| B | £50,000 | 21.6 | 5 | 70 | 91.6 |
| C | £36,000 | 30.0 | 3 | 42 | 72.0 |
C is cheapest but scores lowest overall. B is the most expensive and wins, because the weights said quality mattered most and that was agreed in advance. If a bid is far below the rest, ask the supplier what it includes before you score it.
Bring the evaluators together. Where scores differ by more than a point, each person explains their reason, and the group agrees one consensus score against the descriptors. Record the agreed score and the reason. Do not simply average the scores: averaging hides the disagreement instead of resolving it.
Write down why each bid got its score. US federal buyers must document the strengths, deficiencies, significant weaknesses and risks behind each evaluation. You will want that record too if a supplier challenges the decision or someone asks why the cheapest bid lost.
Use the same notes to give unsuccessful suppliers feedback: their score, the winner's score, and where they lost marks. Good suppliers will bid better next time.
For a one-off purchase with two or three suppliers, a spreadsheet is fine. Our free tender evaluation spreadsheet works as an RFP scoring template in Excel. It gets harder with several evaluators and bids arriving by email in different formats.
In oboloo's RFP software, suppliers respond through a portal link without creating an account, and they can ask clarification questions inside the event. On the free plan you compare responses side by side. eSourcing Plus ($25 per user a month, billed annually, with a 14-day free trial) adds scorable supplier sections with weighted scoring, for example 40% price, 30% quality and 30% risk. A ranked leaderboard shows who won and why, and every score, comment, submission and rescore is logged in a full audit trail.
Where oboloo fits less well: if you only buy this way once a year, a spreadsheet may be all you need, and weighted scoring is a paid add-on rather than part of the free plan. For a wider view of tools, see our guide to tender management software for buyers. For quick price-only requests, see how to compare supplier quotes side by side. For the full process around the scoring, read how to run an RFP as a small business.
A way to compare bids where each criterion gets a weight (a share of 100%) based on how much it matters. Each bid's score on a criterion is multiplied by the weight, and the weighted scores are added up to give a total.
There is no single right answer. Simple, standard goods can carry a high price weight. Complex services usually carry less, so quality can still decide the result. Set it before you see any bids.
The common formula is the lowest price divided by the bid's price, times the maximum price points. The cheapest bid gets full marks and the others get a proportional share.
Yes. UK public bodies under the Procurement Act 2023 and US federal buyers under the FAR must publish the criteria and their relative importance. For private buyers it is good practice: suppliers focus on what you value, and the decision is easier to defend.
Yes. Our free tender evaluation spreadsheet is an Excel template for scoring bids, and the RFP evaluation scorecard builder suggests weights for your purchase.
Related: Excel Scorecard Templates: Simplifying Supplier Performance Evaluation; Streamlining Your Vendor Evaluation Process with Excel Scorecard Templates; Criteria vs Requirements: Key Distinctions in Procurement Evaluation; Comprehensive Guide to Vendor Risk Assessment Templates for Supplier Risk Management.